AWARE [SYSTEMS] Imaging expertise for the Delphi developer
AWare Systems, Imaging expertise for the Delphi developer, Home TIFF and LibTiff Mailing List Archive

LibTiff Mailing List

TIFF and LibTiff Mailing List Archive
April 2004

Previous Thread
Next Thread

Previous by Thread
Next by Thread

Previous by Date
Next by Date

Contact

The TIFF Mailing List Homepage
This list is run by Frank Warmerdam
Archive maintained by AWare Systems



Valid HTML 4.01!



Thread

2004.04.15 00:26 "Large TIFF files", by Lynn Quam
2004.04.15 01:57 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Frank Warmerdam
2004.04.15 02:17 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Lynn Quam
2004.04.15 04:41 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.15 06:05 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Rob Tillaart
2004.04.15 12:23 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Dan Smith
2004.04.15 13:33 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Frank Warmerdam
2004.04.15 21:51 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.16 17:23 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.17 02:50 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.20 08:29 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Rob Tillaart
2004.04.20 14:20 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.21 07:06 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Rob Tillaart
2004.04.20 20:44 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.21 07:30 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Rob Tillaart
2004.04.21 17:54 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.22 07:38 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Rob Tillaart
2004.04.22 18:21 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.22 18:34 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Thomas J Kacvinsky
2004.04.22 18:43 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.22 18:49 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Bob Friesenhahn
2004.04.22 19:52 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Phillip Crews
2004.04.22 20:45 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Andrey Kiselev
2004.04.22 21:06 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.22 21:35 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.22 21:49 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Bob Friesenhahn
2004.04.22 21:59 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.22 22:23 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Bob Friesenhahn
2004.04.22 22:31 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.22 22:34 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.22 23:03 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.22 23:17 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Bob Friesenhahn
2004.04.22 23:59 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.23 15:58 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Leonard Rosenthol
2004.04.26 14:50 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Marco Schmidt
2004.04.23 12:45 "Re: Large TIFF files", by John Aldridge
2004.04.23 13:12 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.23 20:37 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Bob Friesenhahn
2004.04.23 22:31 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.23 22:38 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Bob Friesenhahn
2004.04.23 22:58 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.26 10:03 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.26 14:32 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Bob Friesenhahn
2004.04.26 07:30 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Rob Tillaart
2004.04.26 09:58 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.26 11:06 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Rob Tillaart
2004.04.26 11:28 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.26 12:05 "Re: Large TIFF files", by John Aldridge
2004.04.26 12:33 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.26 12:53 "Re: Large TIFF files: explicitly different format", by Dan Smith
2004.04.26 13:16 "Re: Large TIFF files: explicitly different format", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.26 17:10 "Re: Large TIFF files: explicitly different format", by Chris Cox
2004.04.26 11:38 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Gerben Vos
2004.04.26 12:50 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Joris Van Damme
2004.04.27 06:12 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Rob Tillaart
2004.04.26 16:54 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.23 13:16 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Phillip Crews
2004.04.23 20:28 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Andrey Kiselev
2004.04.23 15:54 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Leonard Rosenthol
2004.04.22 10:32 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Gerben Vos
2004.04.22 18:41 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox
2004.04.22 19:45 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Dan Smith
2004.04.22 20:08 "Re: Large TIFF files", by Chris Cox

2004.04.26 13:16 "Re: Large TIFF files: explicitly different format", by Joris Van Damme

Dan Smith wrote:
> This is more in the nature of "thinking out loud" then a carefully reasoned
> piece of advocacy.

I think it's a very nice piece of advocacy!

I just don't understand anymore what the word 'compatibility' actually means...

> IF
> the formats were logically similar AND THEREFORE support for big TIFF was
> smooth, easy, and fast at the developer level. The typical end-user might see
a
> new "use Big TIFF format never/when needed/always"  checkbox appear in their
> software long before they needed to use it.

You're advocating
- logical extension of 32bit to 64bit
- of course leading to two different formats, in this regard
- but still holding on to logical structure, logic of reading/writing, tag
values and meanings, etc...

Is that right?

This is what I would call the *most compatible* option. It is certainly the
minimum code change option, minimum logic change option, and minimum spec change
option. All TIFF corner stones are perfectly untouched. Implementing this 64bit
support in LibTiff is relatively easy. It leaves the choice of writing 32bit or
64bit TIFF to the higher level. It is exactly what I advocated all along as
*most compatible* option, while you seem to view it as fundamentally
incompatible, and I can see there's logic to that too...



Joris Van Damme
info@awaresystems.be
http://www.awaresystems.be
Download your free TIFF tag viewer for windows here:
http://www.awaresystems.be/imaging/tiff/astifftagviewer.html